
Maybe Conan Doyle was already sick of Holmes by
The Sign of the Four. That's probably why he married off Watson. "He can't record anymore of the know-it-all's exploits if he's tethered to a wife, can he? I'll just scribble in an extra paragraph at the end here, send it off to the printers, and bob's yer uncle! Now I can fully devote the rest of my time to what I'd
really like to write about - a whole slew of books on the Hundred Years War!"
Maybe we'll never know. Or perhaps it's easy to find out, except I'm too lazy to look it up on wiki in favor of my little comedy bit. Perhaps. Perhaps.
So then he had to keep contriving ways of pairing Holmes & Watson together again when he started writing the short stories. The obvious answer is to set some of them in the vague period of time between
Scarlet and
Four. But there are actually only one or two of them in Adventures that can qualify. In
Scandal in Bohemia, he just happens to be in the neighborhood. In
The Man With the Twisted Lip, he bumps into Holmes in an opium den(!) while looking for another friend(!!). In
The Engineer's Thumb he rather unprofessionally recommends the services of Sherlock Holmes to a patient rather than sending the poor fellow to the police as he should have done. But we all know from these stories that the Yard is filled with dunces. Or maybe something else was going on?
Watson just needed an excuse to visit his best friend.
I'd have to think that Mary Morstan Watson was getting pretty cheesed off at this point. The unspoken truth of it all hit me as I was reading the final story of the collection -
The Adventure of the Copper Beeches. In it, Watson is obviously living at Baker Street. He sleeps there. In fact a whole fortnight passes between Holmes' initial meeting with the client and the conclusion of the case with Watson residing at 221B. This has got to be set before his marriage...
Except it isn't. Two continuity references to cases that featured a very married Watson are made in the course of
Copper Beeches, so what's going on here?
Oh, listen to you with your reasonable explanations of continuity errors!
"Watson said he was shot in the shoulder while he was in Afghanistan in one story, but in another it was his leg!" "Wisteria Lodge was set in 1892, despite the fact that Holmes was believed dead from '91 to '94!"
It's not a continuity error!
Mary kicked him out.
She got so sick and tired of the silly bugger making any old excuse to visit his playmate, that she kicked the fool out for a short period (more than a fortnight, I'd think). Even the above cover image supports my theory. Look at Holmes' expression. He's sizing up his client. Now look at Watson's. It plainly says, "Why did this frightful creature have to bother us on bridge night? Why?"
In fact...well, I didn't really want to announce this here, but it seems the appropriate venue, I suppose. I recently found in a dusty old portmanteau a dispatch box filled with some of Conan Doyle's old scribblings (I know! Shocking!), and crammed underneath
The Adventure of The Forty-Niner's Bedpan (a story the world is not yet prepared until I get my finder's fee) is the original unused beginning to the
Copper Beeches. It starts thusly:
It was an unusually sweltering evening in September of 1893. I was walking home after assisting my good friend Holmes. He had had a sizeable amount of roommate applications to sort through and I was able to eliminate them all as possible candidates. Every man-jack of them a complete rotter! Perhaps next week he will have better luck, I thought, and in my absentmindedness tripped over something in the lane. When I looked down, I was surprised to see it was my very own brass-plated stethoscope. I looked up just in time to be clobbered with a handful of my winter underthings. My beautiful wife's usually pleasant features - now twisted with rage - were regarding me from our second storey window.
"Mary!" I cried. "Whatever is the matter?"
"You've been off with him again, haven't you?" she shouted. "I rang you at your practice to see what you'd like for supper, only to discover that you'd left it unattended again! You haven't made a farthing in three weeks and the landlord says we're two months due!"
"But, Mary! Holmes-"
"I wouldn't mind so much if the great detective let you share in his stipend! We could've hocked that blue carbuncle, you know!"
"Sweetheart!"
"Don't you 'sweetheart' me! In fact you can stay with your other sweetheart until you come to your senses!" She raised her arm, getting ready to lob something else into the street. "And you can take this with you!"
"Not my ovaltine!" I ejaculated.
There are just some things a Victorian gentleman doesn't write about.